Friday, June 20, 2025
Asia Democracy Chronicles
Follow Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Features & Analysis
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Articles
    Stateless, twice over

    Stateless, twice over

    Laboring under a tariff threat

    Laboring under a tariff threat

    Left out by the law

    Left out by the law

    Between memory and forgetting: Keeping the spirit of Tiananmen alive

    Between memory and forgetting: Keeping the spirit of Tiananmen alive

    Remembering Liu Xiaobo

    Remembering Liu Xiaobo

    Coming into the light

    Coming into the light

    Desperately seeking sustenance

    Desperately seeking sustenance

    A politicization of faith

    A politicization of faith

    Malaysia’s struggle for democratic deepening: Between reform and restraint

    Malaysia’s struggle for democratic deepening: Between reform and restraint

  • Countries
    • NORTHEAST ASIA
      • China
        • Hong Kong
        • Macau
        • Tibet
      • Japan
      • Mongolia
      • North Korea
      • South Korea
      • Taiwan
    • SOUTH ASIA
      • Afghanistan
      • Bangladesh
      • India
      • Nepal
      • Pakistan
      • Sri Lanka
    • SOUTHEAST ASIA
      • Brunei
      • Cambodia
      • Indonesia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Thailand
      • Timor-Leste
      • Vietnam
    • GLOBAL / REGIONAL
  • Issues
    • Elections
    • Access to Education
    • Access to Health
    • Authoritarianism and Abuse of Power
    • Civil Liberties
    • Discrimination Against Covid-19 Patients and Specific Sectors
    • Gender-based Violence and Child Abuse
    • Governance
    • Labor and Migrant Workers’ Rights
    • Media Freedom – Issues
    • Movement and Migration
    • Privacy and Surveillance
    • Social Protection and Inclusion
      • Peace and Diplomacy
  • Democracy Digest
    • Democracy Digest Archive
  • Asia Through The Lens
    • Northeast Asia
    • South Asia
    • Southeast Asia
    • Regional / Global
  • Democracy Watch
  • Statements
    • Civil Society Statements
  • About
    • Pitch Us
    • Back to ADN
  • Features & Analysis
    • All
    • Analysis
    • Articles
    Stateless, twice over

    Stateless, twice over

    Laboring under a tariff threat

    Laboring under a tariff threat

    Left out by the law

    Left out by the law

    Between memory and forgetting: Keeping the spirit of Tiananmen alive

    Between memory and forgetting: Keeping the spirit of Tiananmen alive

    Remembering Liu Xiaobo

    Remembering Liu Xiaobo

    Coming into the light

    Coming into the light

    Desperately seeking sustenance

    Desperately seeking sustenance

    A politicization of faith

    A politicization of faith

    Malaysia’s struggle for democratic deepening: Between reform and restraint

    Malaysia’s struggle for democratic deepening: Between reform and restraint

  • Countries
    • NORTHEAST ASIA
      • China
        • Hong Kong
        • Macau
        • Tibet
      • Japan
      • Mongolia
      • North Korea
      • South Korea
      • Taiwan
    • SOUTH ASIA
      • Afghanistan
      • Bangladesh
      • India
      • Nepal
      • Pakistan
      • Sri Lanka
    • SOUTHEAST ASIA
      • Brunei
      • Cambodia
      • Indonesia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Thailand
      • Timor-Leste
      • Vietnam
    • GLOBAL / REGIONAL
  • Issues
    • Elections
    • Access to Education
    • Access to Health
    • Authoritarianism and Abuse of Power
    • Civil Liberties
    • Discrimination Against Covid-19 Patients and Specific Sectors
    • Gender-based Violence and Child Abuse
    • Governance
    • Labor and Migrant Workers’ Rights
    • Media Freedom – Issues
    • Movement and Migration
    • Privacy and Surveillance
    • Social Protection and Inclusion
      • Peace and Diplomacy
  • Democracy Digest
    • Democracy Digest Archive
  • Asia Through The Lens
    • Northeast Asia
    • South Asia
    • Southeast Asia
    • Regional / Global
  • Democracy Watch
  • Statements
    • Civil Society Statements
  • About
    • Pitch Us
    • Back to ADN
No Result
View All Result
Asia Democracy Chronicles
No Result
View All Result
Home Asia

Paying to be heard

Online-freedom advocates say that a move in South Korea to have even global content providers pay network-usage fees can have a negative impact on net neutrality even beyond the country’s borders.

byCristina Chi
November 3, 2023
in Asia, Civil Liberties, Northeast Asia, South Korea, Special Feature
Reading Time: 6 mins read
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Seven years after requiring South Korea’s three major Internet service providers (ISPs) to pay additional fees to send data to each other, the country’s legislators are now proposing that global content providers such as Twitch, YouTube, and Netflix pay these ISPs for their data traffic while also risking penalties if they offer bad service. 

The proposed policy is intended to level the playing field among domestic and foreign content providers. But Korea University law professor Kyung Sin Park warned that it may ultimately suppress innovation, push “unicorn” start-ups in Korea to move overseas, and affect the distribution of media among Korean consumers.

More and more, internet service providers in Asian countries are lobbying for internet regulations that will allow content platforms to shoulder the costs of their traffic consumption and data use. (Photo: Shutterstock / Carlos Amarillo)

Speaking at a recent online forum on Internet freedom in South Korea, Park said that the imposition of fees on content providers would also set a “dangerous precedent” for other countries in the Asia-Pacific to follow suit in imposing a similar network-usage fee.

This could collectively throttle net neutrality in the region — a concept that allows open and non-discriminatory access to the Internet for all, he said.

According to The Internet Society, mobile and wireless communications have become “increasingly the primary means of access for users in Asia-Pacific,” making protection of net neutrality a greater imperative in the region. 

Asia-Pacific is estimated to have about 2.8 billion Internet users at present. But with shrinking civic spaces across the region, efforts to protect free speech and the free flow of information rely on the non-interference of actors on what content is shared.

Prateek Waghre, policy director at the Internet Freedom Foundation, an India-based advocacy group focusing on digital rights, describes net neutrality as a principle built on “treating every byte of network equally.”

Just this September, the debate on net neutrality was revived in India after the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) publicized the responses it received from telecom companies to a paper it had floated regarding the regulation of content platforms.

Similar to what Korean ISPs have been pushing for, India’s telecom operators have been arguing that content platforms should shoulder the hefty costs brought about by their heavy traffic consumption and data use. 

Over the years, telecom operators have repeatedly lobbied for and brought up some form of proposal to charge network fees from large traffic generators, said Waghre. 

“In one sense, it looks like they’re asking again and again until they get the answer they want,” he said. “Or there is just seemingly not enough pushback for them to not push ahead with something like this.”

India’s largest telecom operator Jio has even demanded that content providers “contribute” toward network costs to even out the playing field — an argument that it says is “near consensus” among telecom operators across the globe. 

Source: Cyberghost, ProCon, NordVPN, TechTarget, Brookings, CBS, Forbes, Electronic Frontier Foundation (2004 and 2014), Stanford Center for Internet and Society, Scientific American

Bias and algorithms

Besides the possibility of additional charges being passed onto consumers in the form of higher subscription fees, Waghre stressed that the imposition of network costs may lead to a tiered Internet where established players receive preferential treatment from telecom operators.

“When Netflix or Microsoft contributes to your revenue in a significant way,” he said, “you will likely favor them. That’s just how corporate decisions work.” 

Data Ethics PH founder Dominic Ligot, for his part, said that when certain platforms like Facebook, TikTok, and YouTube are promoted with more attractive bundles, it can create a bias in how information is accessed and worsen the spread of false information. 

“It’s because people are often forced to use these platforms as their main way to access the Internet,” he explained, “and these platforms may favor certain information based on algorithms.”

In simple terms, net neutrality is crucial to ensuring that information is shared and accessed by people fairly, said Ligot.

He noted that telecommunications are considered utilities and a provider of essential services, thereby requiring a “balance to be struck” with their demands for additional payment from content providers.

In the traditional set-up, individual users and businesses pay for Internet access and the content and services they use.  For Waghre, the ‘sender pays’ model such as what South Korea is seeking to widen locally can lead to startups and younger companies being crowded out, stifling competition and innovation in the long term.

“That’s why it is worrying,” Waghre said. “What ultimately happens is the telecom provider becomes a gatekeeper of sorts.” 

Waghre also believes that even if proposals to this end have yet to be approved in South Korea and the European Union, strong and vocal support from big telecom players in these countries lend “extra weight” to the Indian government’s consideration of a similar measure.

“The fact that the EU did a consultation around it, I’m sure that had implications,” he said. “You could certainly picture people lobbying, ‘Look, they’re doing this consultation, so we should look as well.'”

In Korea, the implementation of the “sender pays” model after a 2016 law amendment gave ISPs a way to charge content providers Internet access fees based on traffic generated by the latter’s customers. The amendment was supposed to cover both domestic content providers like Naver and Kakao and foreign providers of online content like Netflix, YouTube, and Twitch that use the country’s ISPs. 

But the foreign content providers have so far evaded the rules by reducing the quality of their high-bandwidth content (thus lessening traffic and avoiding high network-usage fees) or limiting domestic availability, often keeping such content outside of South Korea for local ISPs to access. This has led to accusations that foreign content providers are “free-riding” on the Korean network and swimming in profits without paying due fees similar to their domestic counterparts – hence the recent move of the country’s legislators. 

Crushing content creators?

A petition against the proposal has asserted that while Korean lawmakers believe it would only affect giant platforms like YouTube, “most of the people providing content on the big platforms are individual or small to midsize content creators.”

“If content creators have to pay every time people view their content, the world’s most viewed videos such as Baby Shark (100 million views) or Gangnam Style (44 million views) could not exist,” the petition from Open Net Korea read in part. “Could BTS or ‘Squid Game’ achieve their current popularity?” 

At the Digital Rights Asia-Pacific webinar held last 9 October, Park – an Open Net Korea co-founder — also brought up the potential “trickle-down effect” from content providers to consumers. He said that if the proposal pushes through, it would suppress not just innovation but also affect the extent to which platforms are able to host content from small-time content creators.

“For instance,” Park said, “to speak online, the data has to be pushed out to show a video of you. If you are a popular YouTuber, that means a lot of your videos will come out of YouTube. And if a YouTube server is on a certain ISP, that ISP will want to charge YouTube for pushing out a lot of data. And then what is YouTube gonna do? YouTube will have to charge you if you are a popular influencer.”

Park said that a consequence of the 2016 guidelines, an app designed to notify people of COVID-19 hotspots through an announcement system was not fully functional due to its inability to meet demand after paying high interconnection fees.  

Even South Korea’s homegrown video streaming platform Watcha Inc. went downhill due to operational losses from having 10 percent of its revenue going to cover Internet access fees, he said.

Too, while the 2016 regulations have been justified partly as shifting the cost burden from end-users to content providers, they have actually jacked up the cost of Internet access in Seoul compared to other major cities elsewhere — at least five to six times higher than New York and London, eight times more than London and Paris and 10 times more than Frankfurt, according to Park.

He said that any system that makes companies shell out money to deliver data violates the principles of net neutrality as Internet use should not be pre-conditioned on who has the ability to pay.

While the proposed policy in South Korea is far from an explicit censorship of online content, Park pointed out that the Internet is built on a foundational principle of individuals being able to communicate directly with billions without relying on gatekeepers. 

In its petition, Open Net Korea also said that the imposition of a “network-usage fee” on content-sharing companies — and by extension, content providers and consumers — “did not exist in the Internet ecosystem” and had only been “concocted by Korean telcos who wanted to raise more revenues on the Internet.”

Popular online streaming service Twitch has blocked the uploading of video-on-demand (VOD) content from South Korea since January 2023. Analysts blame this on Seoul’s network usage fees. (Photo: Shutterstock / Ink Drop)

“(ISPs) have successfully lobbied the Korean government into basically taking one step back in the age of telephone and postage,” Park said.

“Because that is what the ‘sender pays’ (model) is,” he said. “It’s like a post stamp. And believe it or not, that’s the dream of all ISPs in the world. They want to go back to the age of the telephone where they can play the role of gatekeeper.”  ◉

Tags: GovernanceInternet freedomspecial feature
Cristina Chi

Cristina Chi

Cristina Chi is a Filipino journalist based in Manila who writes about education, legislature, and human rights.

Next Post
China’s property slump pushes financial regulator to roll out loan rule ‘trick’ to help grease the economy

China’s property slump pushes financial regulator to roll out loan rule ‘trick’ to help grease the economy

ADHD, depression the most common mental disorders among Hong Kong primary, secondary schoolchildren, surveys reveal

ADHD, depression the most common mental disorders among Hong Kong primary, secondary schoolchildren, surveys reveal

University of Tokyo asks firms to stop pressuring job-hunting students

University of Tokyo asks firms to stop pressuring job-hunting students

Features and Analysis

  • All
  • Special Feature
Stateless, twice over
Special Feature

Stateless, twice over

byDiwash Gahatraj
June 17, 2025
0

Deported from the U.S. to a homeland that won’t take them back, Bhutanese refugees now find themselves trapped in a...

Read more
Laboring under a tariff threat
Special Feature

Laboring under a tariff threat

byKanika Gupta
June 14, 2025
0

Hundreds of thousands of workers in Sri Lanka – particularly those in the garments and apparel sector – are getting...

Read more
Left out by the law
Articles

Left out by the law

byGafira Qadir
June 9, 2025
0

India’s new criminal law has been in effect for almost a year now, but the country’s transgender community is finding...

Read more
Between memory and forgetting: Keeping the spirit of Tiananmen alive
Analysis

Between memory and forgetting: Keeping the spirit of Tiananmen alive

byAndrew Shum
June 4, 2025
0

Yearly candlelight vigils in Hong Kong remembering the Tiananmen victims may have been extinguished. Yet the embers of activism through...

Read more

Pitch Us A Story

Have a story to tell, nuanced insights, or expert analysis to share with a regional (i.e. Asia), even global, audience? Want to weigh in on specific issues, including those disproportionately affecting specific segments of society, which run the gamut from poverty and inequality to human rights violations? We’d love to hear from you.

We run features, op-eds, analyses, among others, that probe issues around fundamental rights and civil liberties, and illuminate the challenges of governance in Asia.

Yes, I’m Interested

Follow Us

Facebook
Twitter
RSS

©  Asia Democracy Chronicles.

Web Design and Development by Neitiviti Studios.

  • Features & Analysis
  • Countries
  • Issues
  • Democracy Digest
  • Asia Through The Lens
  • Democracy Watch
  • Statements
  • About
No Result
View All Result
  • Features & Analysis
  • Countries
    • NORTHEAST ASIA
      • China
      • Japan
      • Mongolia
      • North Korea
      • South Korea
      • Taiwan
    • SOUTH ASIA
      • Afghanistan
      • Bangladesh
      • India
      • Nepal
      • Pakistan
      • Sri Lanka
    • SOUTHEAST ASIA
      • Brunei
      • Cambodia
      • Indonesia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Thailand
      • Timor-Leste
      • Vietnam
    • GLOBAL / REGIONAL
  • Issues
    • Elections
    • Access to Education
    • Access to Health
    • Authoritarianism and Abuse of Power
    • Civil Liberties
    • Discrimination Against Covid-19 Patients and Specific Sectors
    • Gender-based Violence and Child Abuse
    • Governance
    • Labor and Migrant Workers’ Rights
    • Media Freedom – Issues
    • Movement and Migration
    • Privacy and Surveillance
    • Social Protection and Inclusion
      • Peace and Diplomacy
  • Democracy Digest
    • Democracy Digest Archive
  • Asia Through The Lens
    • Northeast Asia
    • South Asia
    • Southeast Asia
    • Regional / Global
  • Democracy Watch
  • Statements
    • Civil Society Statements
  • About
    • Pitch Us
    • Back to ADN

© 2022 Asia Democracy Chronicles - Designed and Developed by Neitiviti Studios.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In