Thursday, February 9, 2023
Asia Democracy Chronicles
Follow Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Features & Analysis
    • All
    • Articles
    • Commentary
    • Explanatory
    Fear and loathing in Yangon

    Fear and loathing in Yangon

    Deadly air

    Deadly air

    The growing TTP threat

    The growing TTP threat

    All labor, no love

    All labor, no love

    The waste warriors

    The waste warriors

    Trying not to get walled in

    Trying not to get walled in

    Slow breakout from ‘traditional’ work

    Slow breakout from ‘traditional’ work

    Mapping China’s global sway

    Mapping China’s global sway

    Kashmir’s incredible shrinking job market

    Kashmir’s incredible shrinking job market

  • Countries
    • NORTHEAST ASIA
      • China
        • Hong Kong
        • Macau
        • Tibet
      • Japan
      • Mongolia
      • North Korea
      • South Korea
      • Taiwan
    • SOUTH ASIA
      • Afghanistan
      • Bangladesh
      • India
      • Nepal
      • Pakistan
      • Sri Lanka
    • SOUTHEAST ASIA
      • Brunei
      • Cambodia
      • Indonesia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Thailand
      • Timor-Leste
      • Vietnam
    • GLOBAL / REGIONAL
  • Issues
    • Elections
    • Access to Education
    • Access to Health
    • Authoritarianism and Abuse of Power
    • Civil Liberties
    • Discrimination Against Covid-19 Patients and Specific Sectors
    • Gender-based Violence and Child Abuse
    • Governance
    • Labor and Migrant Workers’ Rights
    • Media Freedom – Issues
    • Movement and Migration
    • Privacy and Surveillance
    • Social Protection and Inclusion
      • Peace and Diplomacy
  • Democracy Digest
  • Asia Through The Lens
    • Northeast Asia
    • South Asia
    • Southeast Asia
    • Regional / Global
  • About
    • Pitch Us
  • Back to ADN
  • Home
  • Features & Analysis
    • All
    • Articles
    • Commentary
    • Explanatory
    Fear and loathing in Yangon

    Fear and loathing in Yangon

    Deadly air

    Deadly air

    The growing TTP threat

    The growing TTP threat

    All labor, no love

    All labor, no love

    The waste warriors

    The waste warriors

    Trying not to get walled in

    Trying not to get walled in

    Slow breakout from ‘traditional’ work

    Slow breakout from ‘traditional’ work

    Mapping China’s global sway

    Mapping China’s global sway

    Kashmir’s incredible shrinking job market

    Kashmir’s incredible shrinking job market

  • Countries
    • NORTHEAST ASIA
      • China
        • Hong Kong
        • Macau
        • Tibet
      • Japan
      • Mongolia
      • North Korea
      • South Korea
      • Taiwan
    • SOUTH ASIA
      • Afghanistan
      • Bangladesh
      • India
      • Nepal
      • Pakistan
      • Sri Lanka
    • SOUTHEAST ASIA
      • Brunei
      • Cambodia
      • Indonesia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Thailand
      • Timor-Leste
      • Vietnam
    • GLOBAL / REGIONAL
  • Issues
    • Elections
    • Access to Education
    • Access to Health
    • Authoritarianism and Abuse of Power
    • Civil Liberties
    • Discrimination Against Covid-19 Patients and Specific Sectors
    • Gender-based Violence and Child Abuse
    • Governance
    • Labor and Migrant Workers’ Rights
    • Media Freedom – Issues
    • Movement and Migration
    • Privacy and Surveillance
    • Social Protection and Inclusion
      • Peace and Diplomacy
  • Democracy Digest
  • Asia Through The Lens
    • Northeast Asia
    • South Asia
    • Southeast Asia
    • Regional / Global
  • About
    • Pitch Us
  • Back to ADN
No Result
View All Result
Asia Democracy Chronicles
No Result
View All Result
Home China

Mapping China’s global sway

A new report connects the dots of China’s influence activities in 82 countries. It is a rich database for citizens, researchers, and policymakers to mine for insights as they counter the country’s influence.

Dinna Louise C. DayaobyDinna Louise C. Dayao
December 27, 2022
in China, Peace and Diplomacy, Special Feature
Reading Time: 13 mins read
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

S

hahzeb Jillani thought he had a good grasp of the extent of China’s influence on Pakistan. The veteran Pakistani journalist has spent more than 20 years reporting to and from the South Asian country for global news organizations. And so when he was tapped as the expert who would compile research on Pakistan for the China Index 2022, he was more than confident that his years of experience would serve him well. 

But when the Index was relaunched at the recent China in the World conference in Berlin, Jillani admitted, “When I started working on this project, I had a sense that Pakistan will figure high on the list. But I did not expect that it would be right at the top.” 

The Index is “the first cross-regional project to objectively measure and visualize the People’s Republic of China (PRC)’s overseas influence through comparable data” in nine “domains” or areas from 82 countries. It was conducted and published by the China in the World network, an initiative of Doublethink Lab, a Taiwan-based anti-disinformation NGO.

China’s rising influence is now a global concern. “China’s economic and political footprint has expanded so quickly that many countries, even those with relatively strong state and civil society institutions, have struggled to grapple with the implications,” wrote Erik Brattberg and Evan A. Feigenbaum in an October 2021 paper published on the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace website.

Doublethink Lab organized the two-day China in the World conference, which brought together stakeholders researching the Asian giant’s global influence and its disinformation strategies. Experts from all over the world discussed topics ranging from China in the Balkans to the country’s influence on media in the Global South.

Germany is the highest-ranking European country in the Index. Pakistan, however, is the country most exposed to Beijing’s influence, according to the Index. Seven other Asian countries are in its Top 10.

99 questions

From a regional perspective, China has a wide footprint in East and Southeast Asia. In the Index, the region has an average overall China influence score of 48%. The world average is 32.3%; Europe’s average overall influence score is 24.3%.

The rankings do not merely reflect the opinions of Jillani and the other experts involved in the Index. They all responded to questions about China’s activities in their country in nine areas, with each area having 11 queries: academia, domestic politics, economy, foreign policy, law enforcement, media, military, society, and technology.

Min Hsuan Wu, cofounder and CEO of DoubleThink Lab, told ADC: “Every country answers the 99 questions. If they say ‘yes,’ [they need to] attach the evidence and reference.” The graded responses to all the questions are then summed up to determine the rankings.

China Index 2022 top 10
Rank Country Original score Most influenced domains
1 Pakistan 242 / 380 Technology, Foreign Policy, Military
2 Cambodia 233 / 376 Law Enforcement, Military, Foreign Policy
3 Singapore 228 / 384 Technology, Academia, Economy
4 Thailand 226 / 384 Military, Law Enforcement, Technology
5 Peru 219 / 396 Society, Media, Military
5 South Africa 219 / 396 Technology, Foreign Policy, Domestic Politics
7 Philippines  204 / 380 Domestic Politics, Law Enforcement, Technology
8 Kyrgyzstan 206 / 384 Technology, Law Enforcement, Foreign Policy
9 Tajikistan 194 / 396 Economy, Foreign Policy, Technology
10 Malaysia 189 / 388 Law Enforcement, Technology, Economy, Society
Source: China in the World, Doublethink Lab

How to use the Index

The Index is more than a ranking. It’s a rich database that citizens, researchers, and policymakers can mine for insights as they chart their strategies to counter China’s pervasive influence. Among Beijing’s activities, after all, are Confucius Institutes in colleges and universities around the world, all-expenses-paid media tours in China, journalistic exchanges, investment, and research partnerships.

Wu said that different stakeholders can choose indicators in a specific domain — such as Media, for example — to focus on and work to reduce that indicator in their country. This domain evaluates how the PRC influences public debate and media coverage about China in the Index country.

Civil-society groups and policymakers can look at a country with a low media domain score like Vietnam and compare it with a country with a high media domain score, such as Taiwan. Wu said, “They can then determine whether there’s a policy-level effort that can be implemented.”

Lessons from a low scorer

Taiwan
(Media domain score: 81.8%)
Vietnam
(Media domain score: 10.0%)
Indicator Response Response
1. In my country, there are media organizations that belong to the World Chinese Media (世界华文媒体) network. Yes
Answer (1 / 4)
No
Answer (0 / 4)
2. In my country, there are journalists or media organizations that are members of the Belt and Road Media Cooperation Alliance/Union, the Belt and Road News Alliance, or other Belt and Road media networks that connected to the PRC (e.g., Belt and Road Media Community, Belt and Road Journalists Network, Belt and Road News Network, or B&R TV Networks). Yes
Answer (3 / 4)
No
Answer (0 / 4)
3. In my country, there are journalists, media organizations, or online influencers who have attended all-expenses-paid media tours in PRC. Yes
Answer (4 / 4)
No
Answer (0 / 4)
4. In my country, there are journalists, media organizations, or online influencers who have received training from PRC state-owned media or PRC-connected entities. Yes
Answer (2 / 4)
No
Answer (0 / 4)
5. In my country, PRC state media (including print, radio, and video) is broadcasted or distributed in a local language. Yes
Answer (4 / 4)
No
Answer (0 / 4)
6. In my country, there are local media outlets wholly or partly owned by PRC citizens or corporations. Yes
Answer (3 / 4)
Yes
Answer (1 / 4)
7. In my country, there are media outlets that have delivered cheap or free content provided by PRC state-fund media. Yes
Answer (3 / 4)
No
Answer (0 / 4)
8. In my country, there are regular PRC state media or government advertisements inserted within local newspapers, online news websites, or social media. Yes
Answer (4 / 4)
No
Answer (0 / 4)
9. In my country, there are journalists who have had pressure exerted on them by the PRC, including (but not limited to) public denouncement, revocation of journalist ID, and denial of visa. Yes
Answer (4 / 4)
No
Answer (0 / 4)
10. In my country, there are incidents of media outlets censoring views critical of the PRC government. Yes
Answer (4 / 4)
Skip*
11. In my country, there are media personalities (including reporters, journalists, or commentators) or celebrities who deny the existence of human rights abuses in the PRC (e.g., a media personality that doubts there are re-education camps for Uyghurs in Xinjiang). Yes
Answer (4 / 4)
Yes
Answer (3 / 4)
*Local experts are allowed to skip indicators when they are not applicable or supporting evidence is confidential.
Source: China in the World, Doublethink Lab

A Taiwanese case study

Last year, the China in the World network invited proposals from civil-society groups that wanted to develop projects or activities related to the beta version of the China Index in 2021. Economic Democracy Union (EDU), a civil-society group in Taiwan that aims to resist “Chinese political and commercial influences while safeguarding the democratic governance, sovereignty, and economic independence” of the island nation, received a grant. 

EDU was inspired by the Index domains to understand Chinese influence in a more holistic way, said David Green, Doublethink Labs’ media liaison. “Their analysis was previously very focused on … the economy,” he explained in an email, “but the Index helped them widen their lens to consider instances of elite capture, not just in Taiwan but in places like Singapore, which is where the parent companies of some important Taiwan-focused firms reside.”

EDU documented and published on its website “seven cases of how Chinese capital and other influences threaten Taiwan, demonstrating the impacts of these cases to the general public,” reports Doublethink Lab. “EDU traced how Chinese capital influences major companies and platforms, including Singapore-based eCommerce company Shopee, Hong Kong-based travel platform Klook, as well as several major Taiwanese companies, including the bank CTBC.”

Economic Democracy Union, a Taiwan-based civil society group, drew inspiration from the beta version of the China Index in 2021. It documented and published online seven cases of the threatening influence of Chinese capital in the island nation. (Photo: Economic Democracy Union)

The value of the Index is that it allows researchers, civil-society groups, and policymakers to better grasp the nuances of China’s global influence activities, compare data across countries, and find agreement about how to help their country. 

Journalist Jillani said that the Index provides Pakistanis a framework for citizens to assess a relationship with China that many perceive to be “a dignified relationship.” A press release quoted him as saying as well: “One can only hope that this will encourage Pakistanis to debate the pros and cons of the relationship and what it could mean for the future.”

“The thing I like about China Index is that it is trying to quantify influence but not passing a judgment,” Jillani said at the Index’s relaunch in Berlin. “If influence is growing, is it good or bad? That only a nation can answer and their people can answer.” ●

Dinna Louise C. Dayao is an assistant editor of Asia Democracy Chronicles. She is an experienced independent journalist who received a grant from the Pulitzer Center for her project, “Reporting on Road Safety in the Philippines.” She has written about Asian business and management, tobacco control, and the health risks of trans fats consumption. Dinna’s articles have been published on GMA News, Philippine Star, and Rappler.

 

Tags: Asia-PacificChinaEconomic Democracy UnionIndexmedia
Dinna Louise C. Dayao

Dinna Louise C. Dayao

Dinna Louise C. Dayao is an assistant editor of Asia Democracy Chronicles. She is an experienced independent journalist who received a grant from the Pulitzer Center for her project, “Reporting on Road Safety in the Philippines.” She has written about Asian business and management, tobacco control, and the health risks of trans fats consumption. Dinna’s articles have been published on GMA News, Philippine Star, and Rappler.

Next Post
Electricity tariff revisions only to cover cost – Minister

Electricity tariff revisions only to cover cost - Minister

Bangladesh on high alert to check another Covid outbreak

Bangladesh on high alert to check another Covid outbreak

Mother Nature’s still crying

Mother Nature's still crying

Features and Analysis

  • All
  • Special Feature
Fear and loathing in Yangon
Authoritarianism and Abuse of Power

Fear and loathing in Yangon

byJesua Lynn
February 3, 2023
0

As the world commemorates International Human Rights Day, the Philippines is haunted by the ghosts of its past and the...

Read more
Deadly air
India

Deadly air

byGeetanjali Krishna
February 1, 2023
0

India’s worsening air pollution has made even breathing hazardous to its people’s health.

Read more
The growing TTP threat
Pakistan

The growing TTP threat

byHaroon Janjua
January 25, 2023
0

As the world commemorates International Human Rights Day, the Philippines is haunted by the ghosts of its past and the...

Read more
All labor, no love
Labor and Migrant Workers’ Rights

All labor, no love

byUday Rana
January 19, 2023
0

As the world commemorates International Human Rights Day, the Philippines is haunted by the ghosts of its past and the...

Read more

Asia Democracy Chronicles

Pitch Us A Story

Have a story to tell, nuanced insights or expert analysis to share with a regional (i.e. Asia), even global, audience? Want to weigh in on specific issues afflicting humanity while the deadly virus rages on and wreaks havoc on our old ‘normal’? We’d love to hear from you.

We run features, op-eds, analyses, and other original contents that probe issues around human rights and civil liberties, and illuminate the challenges of democratic governance in Asia as states and societies cope with the Covid-19 pandemic. We cover Southeast Asia, Northeast Asia, and South Asia.

Yes, I’m Interested

Follow Us

Facebook Twitter RSS

Search

No Result
View All Result

© 2021 Asia Democracy Chronicles - Designed and Developed by Neitiviti Studios.

  • Home
  • Features & Analysis
  • Countries
  • Issues
  • Democracy Digest
  • Asia Through The Lens
  • About
  • Back to ADN

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Features & Analysis
  • Countries
    • NORTHEAST ASIA
      • China
      • Japan
      • Mongolia
      • North Korea
      • South Korea
      • Taiwan
    • SOUTH ASIA
      • Afghanistan
      • Bangladesh
      • India
      • Nepal
      • Pakistan
      • Sri Lanka
    • SOUTHEAST ASIA
      • Brunei
      • Cambodia
      • Indonesia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Thailand
      • Timor-Leste
      • Vietnam
    • GLOBAL / REGIONAL
  • Issues
    • Elections
    • Access to Education
    • Access to Health
    • Authoritarianism and Abuse of Power
    • Civil Liberties
    • Discrimination Against Covid-19 Patients and Specific Sectors
    • Gender-based Violence and Child Abuse
    • Governance
    • Labor and Migrant Workers’ Rights
    • Media Freedom – Issues
    • Movement and Migration
    • Privacy and Surveillance
    • Social Protection and Inclusion
      • Peace and Diplomacy
  • Democracy Digest
  • Asia Through The Lens
    • Northeast Asia
    • South Asia
    • Southeast Asia
    • Regional / Global
  • About
    • Pitch Us
  • Back to ADN

© 2022 Asia Democracy Chronicles - Designed and Developed by Neitiviti Studios.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In