Potential candidates have started advertising on Facebook more than a year before the May 2022 elections, spending several thousand to a few million pesos since August 2020, data from the social media platform showed.
A significant shift to online campaigning is expected during the 2022 elections, especially with mobility restrictions imposed during the pandemic, although in-person activities will remain a staple of the campaign, according to Eric Alvia, secretary general of poll watchdog National Citizens’ Movement for Free Elections (Namfrel).
“Less people now read newspapers, and with the shutdown of ABS-CBN, there are less media outlets covering the news. People are gravitating towards social media,” Alvia told the Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism (PCIJ).
One senator, Sherwin Gatchalian, has spent P4.5 million (US$94,000) boosting more than 600 Facebook posts over the past eight months, while former senator Antonio Trillanes IV and his supporters spent more than P1 million (US$20,900) to promote a total of 45 posts.
They are the two biggest ad spenders so far on the social media platform among potential national candidates. It’s an average of P562,250 (US$11,752) in ad spending a month for Gatchalian and about P130,000 (US$2,716) a month for Trillanes.
Gatchalian’s Facebook ads were mostly about his stand on issues, particularly on the education and energy sectors. These were pushed through Gatchalian’s official Facebook page “Sen. Win Gatchalian,” which has more than two million likes and followers, as of this writing.
Trillanes advertised his page and his posts accusing President Duterte of corruption. One of the pages supporting the senator — “We support Trillanes 2022” — also showed bills he authored and sponsored. In some posts, both pages used the same graphics.
Other potential candidates have also started advertising on television and radio. Taguig Rep. Alan Peter Cayetano ran an ad that called for the passage of House Bill No. 8597, which seeks to provide each family with P10,000 (US$209) in cash assistance.
Several ground activities have also been arranged nationwide, including gatherings in support of the presidential candidacy of the survey frontrunner, Davao City Mayor Sara Duterte, the president’s daughter. On Facebook, a few supporters paid for ads to promote her, too.
All these advertisements outside the official campaign period, which begins three months before the polls for national candidates, are not considered premature campaigning. They are not covered by election rules limiting campaign spending based on a 2009 Supreme Court ruling on a petition that sought to ban these early advertisements.
Many local polls
Other early advertisers on Facebook among potential national candidates included Antique Rep. and former senator Loren Legarda, who spent over P400,000; and Sen. Juan Edgardo Angara, who spent more than P200,000 (US$ 4,179) although his second term in the Senate will not end until 2025.
Supporters of Sen. Imee Marcos, daughter of the late dictator Ferdinand Marcos, Public Works Secretary Mark Villar, and Cabinet Secretary Karlo Nograles also paid for ads to promote themselves. Marcos’s term also ends in 2025.
Among members of the House of Representatives, Camarines Sur Rep. LRay Villafuerte, Jr. spent nearly P1 million (US$20,900) and Buhay party-list Rep. Lito Atienza spent over P700,000 (US$14,629).
The Digital 2021: Global Overview report showed that Filipinos spent more time than any country in the world on the internet, particularly on social media. The report was conducted by creative agency We Are Social and social media management platform Hootsuite.
The report also showed that Filipino netizens used social media more than four hours on average daily or nearly double the global daily average of two hours and 25 minutes.
More candidates will be relying on social media for advertising, said Rona Caritos, executive director of the Legal Network for Truthful Elections (Lente). She noted how online campaigning, which was previously only used by national candidates during the 2016 polls, has been tapped by local candidates beginning the 2019 midterm polls.
“[Political advertising] will no longer be concentrated at the national level, especially as most Filipinos are scrolling down their Facebook feeds and are on their phone screens because of the pandemic,” she said.
Indeed, many local politicians, including governors and mayors, have paid for Facebook ads, ranging from less than P200,00 (US$4,179) to nearly P1 million (US$20,900).
Facebook Ad Library
These are data available to the public through Facebook’s Ad Library, a searchable database of ads across Facebook and Instagram. It shows the posts that were boosted on the social media platforms and who paid for them.
There are 4,000 ads in the Facebook database so far, although product placements such as those by fast food chain Chowking PH, the World Food Programme, and Spotify were included in the database.
Clare Amador, Head of Public Policy of Facebook Philippines, said the tool is intended to make advertisers accountable. (Q&A: Facebook tool to mitigate foreign interference, make 2022 polls transparent)
It is also intended to mitigate foreign interference in elections. “We’ve been involved in more than 200 elections around the world since 2017. We know that every election is different, so we take this experience and work closely with local experts to learn what’s most useful to mitigate risks and prevent interference,” Amador told PCIJ.
Facebook uses artificial intelligence to review all ads before they are shown on Facebook and Instagram.
With mobility restrictions imposed during the pandemic, a significant shift to online campaigning is expected in the run-up to the 2022 national polls. In-person activities, however, will remain a staple of the campaign, according to poll watchdog National Citizens’ Movement for Free Elections.
“In certain cases, if an ad is already running and it’s about elections or politics, it can be flagged by automated systems or reported by our community. These ads will be reviewed again and if found to be violating our policy by missing a disclaimer, we will also take it down and require they complete authorizations to continue running it,” Amador said.
James Jimenez, Commission on Elections spokesperson and director for education and information, welcomed the activation of the monitoring tool in the Philippines.
“It’s very important,” he told PCIJ. It will be useful in monitoring election advertising online and make sure candidates will follow spending limits, he said.
“It’s inescapable that Facebook will be a major factor [during the campaign], but hopefully it’s not the only social media platform that people will use,” said Jimenez.
Comelec Resolution No. 104888, detailing rules and regulations implementing the Fair Elections Act, provides rules to govern online campaign spending.
Candidates are mandated to register their web sites and social media pages, including those that endorse the candidates, and report how much they have spent on advertising. However, monitoring was impossible in previous elections and candidates did not report it, said Lente’s Caritos.
Jimenez said Comelec would release more guidelines for online campaigning before the start of the official campaign period in February 2022. (Q&A: Comelec will enforce physical distancing, ban eating during campaign events)
While the Facebook Ad Library shows how much the candidates spend on the social media platform, it is not clear yet how Comelec will treat the ads paid for by their supporters.
“That’s the challenge. What happens if you are a supporter and you boost your blog post that’s promoting someone’s candidacy? We’re still making the rules for that,” Jimenez said.
Monitoring YouTube, too
Beyond monitoring the candidates’ spending, Jimenez, Alvia, and Caritos expressed concerns about misinformation and disinformation spreading online during the campaign.
Other than Facebook, Caritos sees the need to also monitor YouTube as she expects candidates turning to the “largely unregulated” platform for unscrupulous activities.
Facebook is only next to YouTube as the most popular social media platform among Filipino netizens.
“They will be uploading YouTube videos that spread disinformation, change the narrative, and show ‘alternate realities’. That’s something we will see,” Caritos said.
Namfrel’s Alvia said even short video formats, like those on TikTok and Instagram, would likely be used in online campaigning to boost engagement and recall.
He said the 2022 campaign might particularly see a lot of discourse on Covid-19-related assistance from politicians, including, but not limited to, social amelioration, access to vaccines, and livelihood support.
“Social media is more accessible to a lot of people and the content is easier to digest but not necessarily correct,” Alvia said. “Kanya-kanyang version ng katotohanan (People will be coming in with various stories of their own).” — PCIJ.org
________________________________________________
Q&A: New Facebook tool to mitigate foreign interference, make 2022 polls transparent
“The Ads Library and authorization process will provide detailed transparency information around political advertising throughout the election, as well as mitigate foreign interference,” says Facebook Head of Public Policy Clare Amador.
By The Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism (PCIJ)
In a step toward campaign finance transparency in the Philippines, Facebook has started monitoring political advertising in the country through its Ad Library.
It is a publicly available tool that tracks pages paying for political ads, the persons paying for them, the amounts they paid, and the demographics of targeted users, among other information.
The Ad Library shows that several potential candidates in the 2022 elections have started advertising on the social media platform more than a year before the May 2022 polls.
Sen. Sherwin Gatchalian, who is seeking reelection, topped the list. He spent P4.5 million (US$94,000) on Facebook ads from August 2020 to April 2021. (READ: Potential bets start advertising on Facebook as 2022 campaign shifts to social media)
Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism (PCIJ) Executive Director Carmela Fonbuena spoke to Clare Amador, head of policy of Facebook Philippines, about the new tool that will make it easier for poll officials to monitor and regulate election spending.
“We’ve been involved in more than 200 elections around the world since 2017. We know that every election is different, so we take this experience and work closely with local experts to learn what’s most useful to mitigate risks and prevent interference,” Amador said.
The 2022 elections are expected to move significantly online amid mobility restrictions because of the coronavirus pandemic.
Read the Facebook’s response to PCIJ below:
What role are you hoping the FB Ad Library can play in the 2022 Philippine elections?
The ads library and authorization process will provide detailed transparency information around political advertising throughout the election, as well as mitigate foreign interference. It is publicly available to everyone.
We believe that transparency leads to increased accountability and responsibility over time – not just for Facebook but advertisers as well. It’s why we continue to introduce tools that allow elected officials, those seeking office and aiming to influence public opinion to show more information about the ads they run and who’s behind them.
(Advertisers on Facebook are required to submit Philippines identification.)
Does it mean no candidate or supporter will be able to advertise on Facebook without agreeing to register as advertisers?
It is our intention to detect political ads – all ads are reviewed before they’re shown on Facebook or Instagram through a combination of automated (artificial intelligence) and human review.
In certain cases, if an ad is already running and it’s about elections or politics, it can be flagged by automated systems or reported by our community. These ads will be reviewed again and if found to be violating our policy by missing a disclaimer, we will also take it down and require they complete authorizations to continue running it.
(More information on the Ad Library here.)
Based on Facebook’s experiences in other countries, which groups have been able to maximize the database?
We’ve been involved in more than 200 elections around the world since 2017. We know that every election is different, so we take this experience and work closely with local experts to learn what’s most useful to mitigate risks and prevent interference.
The Ad Library is a comprehensive tool that provides a view of ads across Facebook’s apps and services. This transparency tool can be invaluable for election regulators trying to understand which ads are running during their elections, who is responsible for them, how much advertisers and candidates are spending to reach and influence voters, and to analyze additional insights so they can help hold advertisers and Facebook accountable.
Will you be sending the Ad Library to the Commission on Elections?
The Ad Library is publicly available to everyone. We will continue to work with Comelec (Commission on Elections) to find ways to support them in their efforts to hold political advertisers more accountable. – PCIJ.org
